SHARE

Cigarette Butt Leads To NJ Suspect's Arrest In 2012 PA Diner Killing: DA

The alleged gunman in a deadly 2012 Reading shooting is in police custody in New Jersey, according to Berks County prosecutors. 

Vallis Slaughter; Vallis Slaughter in 2012; the cigarette butt taken as evidence in Jersey City. 

Vallis Slaughter; Vallis Slaughter in 2012; the cigarette butt taken as evidence in Jersey City. 

Photo Credit: Berks County District Attorney's Office
Jomaine Case (left) was previously convicted in connection with the 2012 killing of Julio Torres (right). 

Jomaine Case (left) was previously convicted in connection with the 2012 killing of Julio Torres (right). 

Photo Credit: Berks County District Attorney's Office
Video evidence from the March 2012 killing of Julio Torres. 

Video evidence from the March 2012 killing of Julio Torres. 

Photo Credit: Berks County District Attorney's Office

Vallis L. Slaughter, of Jersey City, is being held in Hudson County pending his extradition to Pennsylvania, said the District Attorney's Office on Monday, March 25. 

Investigators believe he killed 34-year-old Julio A. Torres on March 24, 2012. Torres was shot while sitting in his car in the parking lot of the West Reading Diner after a confrontation with suspects, the DA's Office said. 

Jomaine Case was eventually convicted in connection with the shooting but the gunman himself was never identified during the initial investigation, prosecutors said. 

Video evidence showed Case and the shooter were holding Styrofoam cups just before the killing, and both cups were collected for DNA analysis in 2012, authorities said. Detectives had also found a cell phone photo of the suspected shooter during the initial investigation. 

In 2023, as part of a cold case initiative launched by the DA's Office, investigators using facial recognition software determined that the 2012 suspect photo showed Vallis Slaughter. Slaughter was found to be living with his mother on Fulton Avenue in Jersey City, New Jersey, and police began surveilling the home. 

After Slaughter was seen tossing a cigarette butt on the street, detectives recovered it and sent it to Pennsylvania State Police for DNA analysis, authorities said. 

Testing showed Slaughter's DNA matched a sample found on one of the Styrofoam cups recovered from the murder scene in 2012, according to prosecutors. 

Slaughter, 39, was arrested by Jersey City police early on Wednesday, March 20, the DA's Office said. He is charged with murder and related counts and has yet to be arraigned in a Berks County court. 

to follow Daily Voice Rutherford and receive free news updates.

SCROLL TO NEXT ARTICLE